Why Does Death Row Take So Long? The Years Behind the Sentence

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.
Why Does Death Row Take So Long? The Years Behind the Sentence

A judge announces a death sentence.

Then, years later, you see another headline about the same prisoner. He is older. The crime happened decades ago. An execution date has finally been scheduled, or another one has been canceled. The period immediately before that date can also include the tradition of what happens before an execution.

It is reasonable to wonder what happened in between.

Death row takes so long because a death sentence can pass through several kinds of legal review, and carrying it out requires separate decisions and preparations. Appeals are a major part of the explanation. They are not the whole explanation.

A court might order a new sentencing hearing. A governor might postpone an execution. A state might be unable to obtain the drugs it plans to use. Different obstacles can arise at different points.

What looks like one long wait from the outside may actually be several separate periods with different causes.

I think that is the most useful place to begin: a death sentence and an execution date are not the same thing.

Pin

How Long Do People Actually Spend on Death Row?

The Bureau of Justice Statistics reported that prisoners executed in 2023 had spent an average of 279 months under a death sentence, about 23 years and three months.

Prisoners still under a death sentence at the end of that year had spent an average of approximately 22 years on death row. 

Those are two different groups.

The first number measures people whose sentences were carried out that year. The second measures people still waiting when the year ended.

Neither means every prisoner will be executed after twenty-three years. An average is a description of the group measured, not a countdown attached to an individual sentence.

It also matters where you start counting.

“Thirty years after the murder” does not necessarily mean thirty years on death row. The investigation, trial, and original sentencing may have occupied part of that interval.

When I read an execution headline, I look for three dates: the crime, the death sentence, and the execution. They tell different parts of the story.

The First Appeal Checks What Happened in Court

A direct appeal generally examines claimed legal errors in the trial and sentencing proceedings.

That can involve questions about evidence, jury instructions, legal rulings, and whether the sentence was imposed properly. It is different from simply holding the same trial again because the defendant dislikes the result.

The Texas Attorney General’s capital appeals guide distinguishes direct appeals from later habeas proceedings. It also explains that some stages can run alongside one another, so the process is not always a neat sequence of one appeal ending before another starts. 

That helps explain why an outside observer can find the timeline confusing.

One headline might concern the sentence. Another might concern a separate challenge to the conviction. A later ruling might address how the execution would be performed.

All concern the same prisoner, but they may ask different questions.

Willie Francis Survived the Electric Chair. Then Came Round Two

Our account of Willie Francis’s court fight after surviving the electric chair shows why identifying the precise question before the court matters. His execution challenge was not a complete retrial of the original murder case.

A Guilty Plea Does Not Necessarily End Review

You might expect a case to move quickly if the defendant admits the crime and wants the death sentence carried out.

James Robertson’s case complicates that assumption.

In 2014, the Florida Supreme Court required his lawyer to continue pursuing the mandatory appeal despite Robertson’s desire to be executed. The court treated review as a responsibility of the legal system. 

A defendant’s wishes did not eliminate that responsibility at that stage.

That is an important distinction. The state is responsible for establishing a lawful basis for an execution even when the condemned person supports the outcome.

Why Did James Robertson Kill His Cellmate to Get Executed?

Our story about Robertson’s stated reason for killing his cellmate follows that unusual situation.

The broader lesson is that “he confessed” and “the legal process is finished” are different statements.

Later Challenges Can Raise Different Issues

A case can also involve postconviction proceedings, including petitions for a writ of habeas corpus.

In plain language, these ask a court to examine legal grounds for a person’s custody or sentence. They can involve issues different from those addressed through the original trial record.

For prisoners convicted in state court, federal habeas relief is governed by rules that generally require state remedies to be exhausted first. Federal law also places substantial limits on relief when a state court has already decided a claim on its merits. 

This is why “another court is reviewing it” does not necessarily mean that court has unrestricted power to reconsider everything.

The questions can include whether a claim was raised properly, which court should decide it, and what legal standard applies.

Those procedural questions can occupy real time. They also determine whether a court can reach the substance of a claim at all.

An Overturned Sentence Can Send the Case Back

Sometimes a court finds an error requiring further proceedings.

That might affect the conviction, the sentence, or a particular ruling. Those outcomes should not be treated as interchangeable.

Texas Sentenced John Allen Rubio to Death Twice. Here’s Why.

An overturned death sentence does not automatically establish that the defendant was innocent. It may require a new sentencing proceeding while leaving the conviction in place. Rubio’s case offers a concrete example of why a death sentence can take decades to carry out, including a retrial after his first conviction was reversed.

Likewise, a ruling that orders another hearing is not necessarily the final result of that hearing.

The Bureau of Justice Statistics recorded 34 prisoners removed from death-sentence status in 2023 because convictions or sentences were overturned. Its report groups those two reasons together, so that figure should not be described as thirty-four exonerations. 

That distinction matters when judging whether the years of review accomplished anything.

The result may change substantially, even when it does not end in release.

Courts Are Only Part of the Execution Process

A sentence can survive legal review while the execution still faces an obstacle.

Romell Broom’s case provides a concrete example.

Ohio’s failed 2009 execution attempt led to years of litigation. Later, a separate problem affected the execution schedule: the availability of execution drugs.

A 2020 reprieve moved his scheduled execution from June of that year to March 2022. The order expressly required him to remain incarcerated on death row. 

The Death Penalty Information Center reports that the governor cited unavailable execution drugs as the reason for that postponement. 

Those are different causes of delay within one history.

The court fight concerned whether Ohio could make another attempt. The later postponement concerned carrying one out.

Why Did Romell Broom’s Execution Fail? What Happened Next

Our examination of why Broom’s execution failed and what happened afterward follows both parts of that timeline.

A Stay, a Reprieve, and a Commutation Do Different Things

Execution coverage uses several terms that can sound as though they all mean “the prisoner gets more time.”

Their effects differ.

A stay generally pauses a legal action, such as an execution, under the terms of a court order.

A reprieve postpones punishment. Broom’s order is a useful example because it changed the date while preserving his death-row status.

A commutation reduces or changes a sentence. In the federal system, the Justice Department distinguishes it from a pardon, which is an act of forgiveness rather than an erasure of the conviction. 

The practical question is what changed.

Was one date postponed? Was the sentence changed? Was further court review ordered?

Those answers tell us far more than a headline saying an execution was “halted.”

Can the President Stop a State Execution?

The president’s clemency power does not extend to state convictions.

For a state offense, the relevant clemency authority depends on that state’s system, typically involving the governor, a board, or both. Federal clemency belongs to the president. 

That jurisdictional difference helps explain why there is no single national office moving every death sentence toward an execution date.

A Florida state case, an Ohio state case, and a federal prosecution operate under different structures.

It is tempting to compare their timelines as though they were cases waiting in the same line.

They are not.

Why a Last-Minute Filing Does Not Tell the Whole Story

When an execution is approaching, a new filing can look like the start of another delay.

But the filing date alone does not tell us when the underlying issue arose or how long it has been disputed.

A challenge could concern a recently issued order, newly available information, or an execution procedure. It could also repeat an argument courts have already rejected.

Those possibilities need to be examined separately.

I would ask what the filing seeks and what a court actually ordered in response. Filing a request and obtaining a stay are different events.

What Happens If Someone Survives an Execution Attempt?

This is also why our explanation of what happens after someone survives an execution attempt focuses on the facts of each procedure. A new event can produce a legal question that did not exist during the original trial.

The Victim’s Family Is Waiting Too

An execution timeline is often described entirely through the prisoner’s age and years in custody.

The victim’s family may also experience years of hearings, rulings, scheduled dates, and changes.

I do not think it is fair to assign every family one opinion about that process. Some support execution. Others oppose it. Some may want to participate in proceedings, while others want distance from repeated coverage.

Their grief cannot be measured solely by whether an execution occurs.

At the same time, the burden of prolonged proceedings deserves acknowledgment. A case that remains active for decades can keep returning to public attention.

That is one reason I try to name victims in our case stories. A discussion about delays should not make the original loss disappear behind arguments about procedure.

Is Spending Decades on Death Row the Same as a Life Sentence?

No.

A death sentence that remains legally in effect is different from a sentence that has been changed to life imprisonment.

A delay can leave the person under the same sentence with a different date, or with no immediate execution date. It does not necessarily transform the punishment.

The distinction is not merely wording.

It determines what officials may seek to do next, subject to the applicable law and court orders.

For readers, the useful question is whether the sentence itself changed. The number of years that have passed cannot answer that on its own.

Questions About Why Death Row Takes So Long

Do prisoners have unlimited appeals?

No. Review involves deadlines, procedural rules, and limits. Federal habeas law, for example, restricts the circumstances in which relief may be granted.

Does every appeal start the whole case over?

No. Many rulings address a particular issue. A new trial or sentencing proceeding is a specific result, not an automatic consequence of filing an appeal.

Does a canceled execution date mean the prisoner is free?

No. A postponed date can leave the conviction, custody, and death sentence unchanged.

Why can someone remain on death row after losing an appeal?

An appeal’s outcome and the practical ability to carry out an execution are separate matters. Other proceedings or implementation problems may remain.

Is the average wait the same in every state?

No national average should be treated as a rule for an individual state or prisoner. The relevant jurisdiction and case history matter.

Does a long delay prove the conviction was wrong?

No. The length of the timeline alone does not establish guilt, innocence, or the merits of a legal challenge.

The Question Behind the Execution Headline

When I see that a prisoner has been executed decades after the crime, I want to know where those years went.

Which court reviewed the conviction?

Did a ruling change the sentence?

Was an execution postponed for a legal question, an executive decision, or a practical obstacle?

Those questions make the history understandable.

“Appeals took forever” may describe someone’s frustration. It rarely explains an entire case.

A death sentence begins a process with consequences for the prisoner, the victim’s family, and the people responsible for carrying it out. Understanding the wait requires following the decisions between the sentence and the final headline.

By Miles Rowan for Stories in the Static, examining criminal cases through overlooked evidence, unresolved questions, and the lives behind the headlines.

Scroll to Top