
At about 8:58 p.m., Courtney Pingleton allegedly removed her blood pressure cuff, looked toward the nurses’ station, and walked out of a hospital room.
She was there for a medical evaluation.
She was also under arrest.
According to the account of a deputy’s probable cause statement published by the Moberly Monitor-Index, hospital security footage then showed her running outside and heading toward U.S. 63.
For a time, staff believed she had gone for a CT scan.
Instead, authorities say, a woman arrested following an alleged hammer attack had left the building. The evening’s assault investigation was becoming a nighttime search.
By the time officers found her, more than two hours had passed.
A Huntsville assault call started the evening
The case began around 6 p.m. Monday, November 2, when Randolph County deputies responded to a reported assault in Huntsville.
They found a woman with blood on her and a rag pressed against the upper left side of her head. A deputy described a raised, swollen area at the injury site.
The woman identified Courtney M. Pingleton as the person who had attacked her.
Pingleton, 34, of Moberly, now faces a first-degree assault charge filed as a Class A felony and a separate misdemeanor charge of escape or attempted escape from custody.

Those are accusations. Pingleton is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
The local report tracing the assault allegation and hospital departure describes two sharply different accounts of the confrontation, followed by a sequence investigators say was captured on cameras.
That combination is what makes this case more than a startling headline.
There is an injured woman’s account. There is the accused woman’s denial. Then there is what authorities say happened after the arrest.
The victim described a light in her eyes and a hammer blow
According to the probable cause account, the injured woman said Pingleton had been drinking, moved close to her, and directed a light into her eyes.
She told Pingleton to move it.
The woman alleged that Pingleton then struck her in the head with a hammer.
Deputies reported that she identified Pingleton repeatedly. The Randolph County Ambulance District transported her to a Columbia hospital for emergency treatment.
The report does not provide a later medical update establishing her condition or recovery.
I would keep that fact in view as the story moves toward the hospital search.
While attention shifted to finding the suspect, another woman was receiving emergency care for a head injury. Her experience does not become less important because the evening took another dramatic turn.
Deputies found Pingleton barefoot in Huntsville
At approximately 7:22 p.m., deputies located Pingleton walking barefoot through front yards along East Clay Street.
The deputy described slurred speech, watery eyes, and an odor of alcohol. According to the statement, Pingleton acknowledged drinking.
After receiving a Miranda warning, she agreed to speak.
But her explanation differed from the victim’s.
Pingleton said she had defended herself
“The old girl was assaulting me, I defended myself,” Pingleton reportedly told the deputy.
She said the other woman punched her first.
She denied using a hammer.
According to the report, she described responding by swinging at the woman and striking her face. The deputy also documented a small red mark beneath one of Pingleton’s eyes.
Pingleton reportedly said the disagreement concerned someone being held at the Randolph County Jail.
That gives investigators an alleged subject of the argument. It does not establish the relationship between the women, explain the entire dispute, or settle who initiated physical violence.
Those questions should remain open until evidence establishes the answers.
The visible injuries and the competing accounts will matter. A self-defense claim is part of the case, rather than something to leave out because it interrupts a more dramatic version of events.
The arrest came before the hospital visit
Pingleton was arrested at 7:46 p.m.
Because she reported an injury and appeared intoxicated, she was taken to a Moberly hospital for evaluation before jail booking.
Two hospital trips now formed part of the evening.
The injured woman from the Huntsville address had been transported to Columbia. Pingleton was taken to a hospital in Moberly.
Keeping those destinations straight matters. They were different people receiving care in different places.
At the Moberly hospital, Pingleton’s handcuffs were removed for medical assessment, including planned CT scans.
Being evaluated did not mean she had been released from custody.
That distinction would become central to the second charge.
A disturbance in the lobby added another complication
During the hospital visit, a man connected to Pingleton reportedly caused a disturbance in the lobby.
He was escorted outside.
The report does not establish that he helped her leave or that the disturbance was a coordinated distraction.
It is an unusual detail, and it is easy to imagine a larger plan around it.
But imagining one would move beyond the facts.
What the account establishes is that a disturbance occurred during a hospital visit that authorities say later ended with Pingleton leaving without permission.
Then the cameras recorded her leaving
The deputy’s body camera remained in the hospital room.
According to the probable cause statement described in the newspaper, it recorded Pingleton removing the blood pressure cuff, looking toward the nurses’ station, and walking toward an exit on the building’s west side.
Hospital security footage reportedly showed her running outside and heading east toward U.S. 63.
I find the blood pressure cuff detail especially striking.
It is such an ordinary part of being in a hospital. Staff put it on, take readings, and continue the examination.
Here, investigators allege that removing it was one of the steps in leaving custody.
The reported camera sequence from inside and outside the hospital places the departure at about 8:58 p.m.
The available account does not tell us exactly when staff realized she was missing or reconstruct every movement inside the building. It does say she was initially thought to have gone for her scan.
That misunderstanding gave the evening its next turn.
The search brought a warning to nearby residents
Multiple agencies searched near Moberly Regional Medical Center.
The Randolph County Sheriff’s Office warned residents about an active manhunt and a heavy law enforcement presence.
People were asked to secure their doors and windows, remain alert, report suspicious activity, and avoid the immediate area.
ABC 17’s coverage of the warning near the medical center documented those instructions as the search unfolded. Its updated coverage later reported that the suspect had been detained.
An alert like that changes how people read an ordinary evening.
The important information becomes immediate and practical: where officers are searching, what residents should do, and whether the person has been found.
For those receiving the warning before the fuller account appeared, the hospital search was the visible part of a story that had started hours earlier in Huntsville.
Officers found her near Taylor Street
At 11:24 p.m., officers located Pingleton near Taylor Street in Moberly.
According to the report, she was hiding near a cemetery, approximately two-tenths of a mile southwest of the hospital.
That is close enough to make the duration striking.
The interval between her reported departure at 8:58 p.m. and her discovery at 11:24 p.m. was two hours and 26 minutes.
It does not tell us her route or how long she spent at the location where officers found her. We should not turn those missing movements into an invented chase through yards or a cemetery.
The deputy interpreted the removal of medical equipment, unauthorized departure, and subsequent hiding as evidence of an intentional effort to evade custody.
Local radio reporting said the sheriff’s office announced the search had ended and an all-clear had been issued shortly before midnight.
The November 2 search is over. Pingleton was found that night.
What the charges mean for this case
The Monitor-Index reported first-degree assault filed as a Class A felony under the section involving serious physical injury or a special victim.
The charge should not be rewritten as attempted murder. That is not the charge identified in the supplied report.
Nor should the charging description be used to guess the victim’s age, occupation, or other characteristics.
Missouri’s first-degree assault statute distinguishes the offense’s classification according to specified circumstances. The particular allegation must be understood through the charging records and evidence in this case.
The escape or attempted escape allegation is a separate Class A misdemeanor.
The alleged assault and the alleged hospital departure therefore raise different questions. Evidence concerning one does not automatically resolve the other.
What remains unanswered
The November 3 report does not establish the injured woman’s latest medical condition.
It also does not provide a bond amount, plea, next hearing date, or a complete explanation of how supervision was being handled when Pingleton left the hospital room.
Those details may emerge later.

The same restraint matters when examining the allegations in the Evan Bednarz-Kelly case: a probable cause statement presents an investigator’s basis for an accusation. It is not the final resolution of conflicting accounts.
Here, Pingleton’s denial of using a hammer and her claim of self-defense belong alongside the victim’s allegation and the deputy’s observations.
The cameras may help establish what happened at the hospital. They do not independently establish what happened during the earlier confrontation in Huntsville.
Questions about the Huntsville assault and Moberly hospital search
Who is Courtney Pingleton?
Courtney M. Pingleton is a 34-year-old Moberly woman charged in Randolph County following an alleged November 2 assault in Huntsville and a reported departure from hospital custody later that evening.
What is she accused of doing in Huntsville?
Authorities allege that she struck another woman in the head with a hammer. Pingleton denied using a hammer and said she acted in self-defense after being punched.
Why was she taken to a hospital instead of directly to jail?
According to the report, she said she was injured and appeared intoxicated. Deputies took her for medical evaluation before booking.
How did she allegedly leave the hospital?
The reported camera evidence shows her removing a blood pressure cuff, leaving the room, and exiting the building. Authorities say she did not have permission to leave.
Was she found inside a cemetery?
The report says officers found her hiding near a cemetery by Taylor Street. It does not establish that she was inside the cemetery.
How long was she missing from the hospital?
The reported departure and discovery times were 8:58 p.m. and 11:24 p.m., an interval of two hours and 26 minutes.
Is the manhunt still active?
No. Officers found Pingleton Monday night, and an all-clear was subsequently announced.
Has she been convicted?
The November 3 account reports charges, not a conviction. Pingleton is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
Written by the Stories in the Static team, following unusual local cases through reported evidence, court developments, and the people affected.








